The 20 Best Eyeliner Pencils I’ve Tried for Bold Looks

The The 20 Best Eyeliner Pencils I’ve Tried for Bold Looks of 2026, Reviewed and Compare

  • Sep 3, 2026
  • GetBestProduct Team

Top Picks

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Stick - Pitch Black

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil - Pitch Black

Pros

  • Long-lasting: With a wear time of up to 36 hours, you can rely on this eyeliner through any situation.
  • Vivid Pigmentation: The color payoff is impressive, providing rich and opaque lines.
  • Wide Range of Shades: The variety in finishes allows for creativity and personal expression.
  • Ease of Application: The glide-on formula makes application smooth and effortless.

Cons

  • Removal Difficulty: Due to its long-lasting nature, users may find it challenging to remove at the end of the day.
  • Breakage Potential: As with many pencil eyeliners, there is a risk of breakage if excessive pressure is applied while applying or sharpening.

Key Features

  • 36 Hour Wear: Enjoy a waterproof, smudge-proof, and fade-proof eyeliner that lasts all day without touch-ups.
  • Matte and Metallic Finishes: Choose from an array of shades with both matte and metallic options to suit your style.
  • High Impact Color: The powerfully pigmented formula delivers dramatic looks with just one stroke.
  • Cruelty-Free: NYX stands by their commitment to cruelty-free cosmetics; no animal testing involved.
  • Versatile Use: Perfect for creating various eye makeup looks, from everyday styles to dramatic artistry.

If you're on the hunt for a reliable eyeliner that can withstand the test of time, look no further than the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Wear Liner Stick. This long-lasting eyeliner pencil in Pitch Black is designed to deliver intense pigmentation and remarkable durability, making it a top choice for makeup enthusiasts. With its impressive 36-hour wear, this eyeliner promises not only bold color but also exceptional performance throughout the day and night.

Lancôme Drama 24H Longwear Waterproof Eyeliner Gel Pencil

Lancôme Drama - 24H Longwear Waterproof Eyeliner Gel Pencil

Pros

  • Long-lasting formula that stays put for up to 24 hours.
  • Multiple finishes allow for versatile makeup looks.
  • Easy to apply with a smooth glide that enhances your eye definition.
  • Available in a wide range of colors suitable for various skin tones.
  • Reputable brand known for high-quality cosmetics.

Cons

  • Some users may find the price point on the higher side compared to drugstore alternatives.
  • The creamy formula may require careful application to avoid excess product.
  • Limited availability of certain shades may be frustrating for some customers.

Key Features

  • 24H Waterproof Gel Pencil: Designed for long-lasting wear, this eyeliner can withstand even the most demanding days.
  • No Smudging, Flaking, Fading, or Transferring: Once set, this eyeliner remains intact, allowing you to look your best without constant touch-ups.
  • Blendable Formula: The creamy consistency allows you to blend right after application for a softer look before it sets.
  • Available Shades: Choose from 8 universal shades offered in three striking finishes - matte, metallic, and glitter.
  • Renowned Brand: Lancôme has a rich history of beauty innovation since its founding in 1935, ensuring quality and elegance in every product.

The Lancôme Drama - 24H Longwear Waterproof Eyeliner Gel Pencil is a must-have for anyone looking to achieve stunning eye makeup that lasts all day. With its ultra-creamy texture, this eyeliner pencil promises dramatic color without the worry of smudging or fading. If you’re seeking an eyeliner that combines luxury with performance, this product might be just what you need.

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eyeliner Stick - Waterproof & Pigment-Rich

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Liner Stick | Non-Creasing, Pigment-Rich, Waterproof, Fine-Tip Eyeliner with Built-in Sharpener

Pros

  • Highly pigmented, providing rich color pay-off.
  • Long-lasting wear, suitable for all-day use.
  • Versatile application for both sharp and soft looks.
  • Built-in sharpener ensures precision without the need for extra tools.
  • Waterproof properties make it ideal for wear in various weather conditions.

Cons

  • Some users may find it slightly difficult to remove compared to non-waterproof options.
  • The price point may be higher than other drugstore alternatives.

Key Features

  • Swipe-and-Go Lining and Defining: Easily transitions from sleek, defined lines to soft, smokey eyes.
  • 24-Hour Waterproof, Life-Proof Wear: Provides long-lasting, non-settling, non-creasing, non-flaking, and non-smudging color that stays true all day.
  • Pigment-Rich Shades: Offers a range of creamy shades that enhance your eye makeup with vibrant depth.
  • Creamy, Blendable Formula: Glides on smoothly and allows for easy smudging to create instant smokey looks.
  • Fine-Tip Design: The precise tip enables effortless lining and defining of your eyes.

The Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Liner Stick is a versatile eyeliner designed for those who want to achieve both defined and softer, smokey looks effortlessly. With its creamy, blendable formula and fine-tip design, this eyeliner stick allows you to swipe and go, making it a practical choice for your makeup routine.

Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 2 Ebony Eyeliner by Make Up For Ever

Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 2 Ebony by Make Up For Ever for Women - 0.04 oz Eyeliner

Pros

  • Long-lasting formula keeps your look fresh all day
  • Intense pigmentation provides bold color payoff
  • Convenient built-in sharpener enhances usability
  • Gentle formula suitable for sensitive eyes
  • Easy to apply, even for beginners

Cons

  • Requires sharpening, which may lead to product waste
  • Color selection is limited to a few shades

Key Features

  • Waterproof, sweat-proof, and smudge-proof eyeliner for 24HR wear
  • Ultra-pigmented formula for vibrant color
  • Glide-on texture for easy application
  • Built-in sharpener for precision
  • Safe on the waterline
  • Ophthalmologist-approved for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes

The Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 2 Ebony by Make Up For Ever is a standout choice for anyone in search of a reliable eyeliner that can withstand the test of time. Designed for a 24-hour hold, this waterproof, sweat-proof, and smudge-proof formula ensures your eye makeup stays intact throughout the day, regardless of how busy your schedule gets. Its ultra-pigmented color glides on effortlessly, making application smooth and precise. Notably, the built-in sharpener adds to the ease of use, giving you ultimate control over your eyeliner’s tip.

Furthermore, this eyeliner is not only effective but also safe for sensitive eyes. It has been ophthalmologist-approved, which means it’s suitable for contact lens wearers and those with delicate skin around the eyes. If you're looking for an eyeliner that delivers both performance and safety, the Aqua Resist Color Pencil should be at the top of your list.

Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner Pencil - Xtreme Black

Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner Pencil - 202 Xtreme Black

Pros

  • Easy application due to its smooth glide.
  • Rich, deep black pigment that enhances eye definition.
  • Stays in place throughout the day, minimizing the need for reapplication.
  • Safe ingredients appeal to those concerned about cosmetic additives.

Cons

  • Some users may find the pencil form less convenient than liquid alternatives.
  • The price point may be higher compared to drugstore options.

Key Features

  • Pencil Form: The eyeliner comes in a pencil form that glides smoothly for easy application.
  • Matte Finish: The black color provides a matte, smudge-proof finish that stays put all day.
  • Phthalate Free: Made with phthalate-free materials, this eyeliner ensures a safe and healthy application.
  • Full Coverage: It provides full coverage that helps define and accentuate your eyes.
  • Long Lasting: Expect the eyeliner to stay put for hours without smudging or fading.

If you're looking for a reliable eyeliner that offers both precision and longevity, the Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner Pencil in 202 Xtreme Black might just be the product you need. With a reputation for high-quality cosmetics, Pat McGrath delivers an eyeliner that promises to enhance your eye makeup game without the hassle of frequent touch-ups.

Aqua Resist Color Pencil - Limitless Brown Eyeliner by Make Up For Ever

Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 04 Limitless Brown by Make Up For Ever for Women - 0.04 Eyeliner

Pros

  • Delivers high-quality results consistent with professional standards.
  • Compact and easy to carry, perfect for touch-ups on the go.
  • Works well for both subtle and bold eye looks.
  • Durable formula ensures long-lasting wear throughout the day.

Cons

  • Only available in a limited color range, which may not suit all preferences.
  • Some users may find the texture to be harder than expected upon first use.
  • The price point may be higher compared to other drugstore alternatives.

Key Features

  • Premium Quality: This color pencil provides professional-grade performance through its advanced formula.
  • Effective Results: Regular use ensures noticeable benefits, enhancing your eye makeup effortlessly.
  • Versatile Use: Suitable for daily application as well as various makeup looks, it's a staple for any beauty collection.
  • Quality Formulation: Created with carefully selected ingredients to prioritize safety and satisfaction.
  • Make Up For Ever Excellence: A brand known for its commitment to innovation and quality in personal care products.

The Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 04 Limitless Brown by Make Up For Ever is a premium eyeliner that promises to deliver exceptional quality and performance. With a compact size of just 0.04 oz, this product is designed for women who value precision and durability in their makeup routine. The formulation is meticulously crafted to ensure effective results with each use, making it a worthy addition to your daily beauty arsenal.

Aqua Resist Graphic Pen - Black | Make Up For Ever Eyeliner

Aqua Resist Graphic Pen - Black by Make Up For Ever for Women - 0.01 oz Eyeliner Pen

Pros

  • Exceptional longevity—lasts up to 24 hours
  • Intense black color that stands out
  • Easy to apply with a felt-tip design
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes, reducing irritation risks
  • Resistant to water, sweat, and smudges, perfect for all-day wear

Cons

  • Some users may find the tip too thick for intricate designs
  • Initial drying time can vary, requiring careful application
  • May require a special remover for complete removal

Key Features

  • 24-hour ultra-black pigmentation for intense color payoff
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof formula ensures long-lasting wear
  • Felt-tip applicator allows for precise application
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Designed for both classic lines and graphic looks

The Aqua Resist Graphic Pen - Black by Make Up For Ever is a highly acclaimed eyeliner that promises to elevate your makeup game. With a rating of 4.1 based on 29 reviews, this eyeliner pen is designed for those who want bold, precise lines without the worry of smudging or fading throughout the day. Its unique formula makes it an essential addition to your beauty arsenal.

Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl Longwear Eyeliner Pencil

Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl - Longwear Eyeliner Pencil

Pros

  • Exceptional staying power that lasts all day without fading.
  • Variety of colors available to suit different styles and occasions.
  • Perfectly defines and contours eyes for a captivating look.
  • Luxury brand reputation associated with quality and innovation.

Cons

  • Some users may find the creamy texture challenging for precise detailing.
  • Higher price point compared to drugstore alternatives.

Key Features

  • Smudgy & Creamy-Smooth: The eye pencil glides on effortlessly, allowing you to create both defined lines and softer, blended looks.
  • Long-Wear: Once applied, it stays put throughout the day, resisting smudging and flaking to maintain that freshly-applied look.
  • Decadent Color: Offers rich pigmentation that enhances your eyes with a striking effect.
  • Easy Blending: The creamy formula is designed for easy blending, giving you versatility in how you apply it.

The Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl is a longwear eyeliner pencil that stands out in the crowded market of eye makeup products. With a rating of 4.6 from over 1,500 reviews, this product has garnered attention for its smooth application and rich color payoff. Designed to deliver a blend of functionality and luxury, this eyeliner is perfect for those looking to enhance their eye makeup routine.

Artist Color Pencil - Limitless Brown by Make Up For Ever

Artist Color Pencil - 608 Limitless Brown by Make Up For Ever for Women - 0.04 oz Makeup

Pros

  • Multi-functional use across different facial features
  • Easy to apply due to its creamy texture
  • The neutral color complements a variety of looks
  • Stays in place without smudging
  • Highly rated with an average score of 4.6 from 460 reviews

Cons

  • Some may find the creamy formula too soft for precise lines
  • Availability may be limited based on location

Key Features

  • Versatile pencil suitable for eyes, lips, and brows
  • Creamy and blendable formula for easy application
  • 'Limitless Brown' shade provides a natural look
  • Long-lasting and smudge-proof for reliable wear
  • Suitable for all skin tones

The Artist Color Pencil - 608 Limitless Brown by Make Up For Ever is designed to help you define your eyes, lips, and brows with ease. This versatile pencil offers a neutral shade that works well for various applications, making it a staple in any makeup kit. The creamy and blendable formula allows for precise application, ensuring that you can achieve your desired look effortlessly. With its long-lasting wear and smudge-proof properties, this pencil not only enhances your features but also stays put throughout the day.

Artist Color Pencil - 506 Endless Cacao by Make Up For Ever

Artist Color Pencil - 506 Endless Cacao by Make Up For Ever for Women - 0.05 oz Pencil

Pros

  • Highly versatile product for multiple uses.
  • Comfortable matte finish ideal for different occasions.
  • Great for both natural and bold makeup looks.
  • Cult-favorite status indicates widespread positive feedback.
  • Easy to blend with other products.

Cons

  • Some users may find the creamy formula can smudge if not set properly.
  • Limited shade range compared to traditional lip or eye pencils.

Key Features

  • Ultra-blendable formula allows for seamless application.
  • Can be used on lips, brows, eyes, and face.
  • Offers a creamy texture that glides on effortlessly.
  • Long-lasting wear keeps your look intact throughout the day.
  • Available in a versatile shade, 506 Endless Cacao.

The Artist Color Pencil - 506 Endless Cacao by Make Up For Ever is a versatile cosmetic tool that has garnered a cult following among makeup enthusiasts. This ultra-blendable pencil can be used across various areas of your face, including your lips, brows, and eyes, making it an essential item for anyone looking to create looks ranging from natural to bold. Its creamy formula ensures a long-lasting wear while providing a comfortable matte finish.

Aqua Resist Smoky Shadow - 6 Earth by Make Up For Ever

Aqua Resist Smoky Shadow - 6 Earth by Make Up For Ever for Women -0.049 oz Eye Shadow

Pros

  • Long-lasting: The waterproof feature means this eyeshadow stays put all day.
  • Easy Application: The stick format allows for quick and effortless use.
  • Versatile Use: Can serve multiple purposes, saving you time and effort.
  • Precision Sharpener: Built-in sharpener ensures you get the precision you need for detailed looks.

Cons

  • Limited Shade Range: Currently available in only one earthy tone.
  • May Require Setting: For those with oily eyelids, a setting powder may be needed for extra durability.

Key Features

  • Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick: Designed to be transfer-proof and waterproof for lasting wear.
  • Multi-Use Eyeshadow: Functions as an eyeshadow, eyeliner, and even as a blush.
  • Lightweight Formula: The formula glides on easily, providing smooth application.
  • Vibrant Earthy Tone: Comes in a shimmery earthy brown shade that enhances your natural look.
  • Suitable for All Skin Types: Ideal for both men and women, making it highly versatile.

The Aqua Resist Smoky Shadow - 6 Earth by Make Up For Ever is a versatile, vegan-friendly eyeshadow stick that has quickly gained a reputation for its impressive performance. With a 5.0 rating from 5 reviews, it stands out for its ability to deliver blendable and creaseless color that lasts throughout the day. If you're looking for an eyeshadow that can withstand various elements such as water, sweat, and smudging, this product could be worth considering.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner - Waterproof Black Eyeliner

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Black, Vegan Formula

Pros

  • Long-lasting Wear: The waterproof formula means you can count on it staying put all day without needing touch-ups.
  • Easy to Use: Thanks to its flexible tip, you can achieve precision without any struggle, making it suitable even for beginners.
  • Great Pigmentation: The intensely pigmented black provides a striking contrast that enhances any eye look.

Cons

  • Initial Learning Curve: Some users may need time to adjust to the brush tip to achieve their preferred line thickness.
  • Potential for Clumping: If not applied correctly, there is a chance of clumping during application.

Key Features

  • Waterproof Matte Finish: Enjoy a long-lasting cat-eye look with intense black pigmentation that doesn't smudge or fade throughout the day.
  • Precise Tip: The ultra-precise and flexible brush tip allows for fluid application, giving you control over the thickness of your lines.
  • Versatile Application: Whether you prefer fine and natural lines or broad and bold strokes, this eyeliner adapts to your desired look effortlessly.
  • Cruelty-Free: NYX is certified by PETA as a cruelty-free brand, ensuring that no animals were harmed in the making of this product.
  • Award-Winning: Recognized as a 2025 Allure Best of Beauty Winner, this eyeliner has received acclaim for its performance and quality.

Specifications

  • Brand: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
  • Product Type: Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
  • Color: Black
  • Vegan Formula: Yes
  • User Rating: 4.5 out of 5
  • Review Count: 107,779

If you're on the hunt for a reliable liquid eyeliner that can deliver sharp, defined lines and withstand the test of time, look no further than the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner. This waterproof eyeliner is designed to help you create everything from delicate cat eyes to bold winged looks with ease. Its vegan formula ensures that you can feel good about your choice while achieving stunning eye makeup.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Aqua Green Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil, Aqua Green

Pros

  • High pigmentation provides a bold color payoff.
  • Long-lasting formula keeps eyeliner fresh all day.
  • Easy to apply and control for precise application.
  • Cruelty-free commitment aligns with ethical consumer choices.

Cons

  • Some users may find the creamy texture too soft for their preference.
  • The vibrant pigment may not suit everyone's taste for everyday wear.

Key Features

  • Retractable Eye Liner: Enjoy the ease of use with a twist-up design that eliminates the need for sharpening. Achieve defined lines effortlessly, mimicking the precision of liquid eyeliner.
  • Smudge Proof and Smooth: Glide on this smudge-proof formula that is engineered to withstand heat and humidity, preventing any unsightly bleeding.
  • Variety of Shades: Available in 15 captivating colors, from natural tones to vibrant shades, allowing for endless creative possibilities.
  • Cruelty-Free: Feel good about your makeup choices as NYX is recognized by PETA as a cruelty-free brand, ensuring no animal testing.
  • Complementary Products: Expand your eye makeup collection with additional products from NYX, including eyeshadow palettes, false eyelashes, and more.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil in Aqua Green is designed to elevate your look with its vibrant hue, making your eyes pop like never before. This creamy eyeliner pencil boasts intense pigmentation, ensuring that your eye makeup stands out whether you're going for a subtle or bold style. With a reputation for long-lasting wear, this eyeliner keeps your look intact throughout the day.

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Eyeliner - All-Day Pigment-Rich Liner

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Eyeliner | All-Day, Pigment-Rich Liner | Sweat, Humidity & Transfer-Resistant, 0.004 Ounce

Pros

  • Long-lasting Formula: Stays put throughout the day without fading or smudging.
  • Easy to Apply: The smooth texture allows for effortless application and precision.
  • Versatile Use: Suitable for a wide range of occasions, whether casual or formal.
  • Transfer-Resistant: Maintains its integrity in various conditions, making it perfect for active users.

Cons

  • Price Point: It may be considered pricey compared to some drugstore alternatives.
  • Limited Color Range: Depending on your preferences, you might find fewer shades available than you'd want.

Key Features

  • Richly Pigmented Waterproof Liner: Defines eyes with color that lasts throughout the day, ideal for humid conditions or active lifestyles.
  • Smooth Application: The formula is designed to glide on lids smoothly and evenly, allowing for precise application every time.
  • Intense Color Definition: Delivers pure, crisp color with pigment that resists water, sweat, and transfer.
  • Swivel-Up Pencil Design: Makes it easy to create a variety of looks, from subtle to bold.

The Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Eyeliner is designed for the individual who needs a reliable eyeliner that can withstand the rigors of daily life, including sweat, humidity, and even intense workouts. With a commitment to delivering pigment-rich color that lasts all day, this eyeliner aims to provide both versatility and durability in your makeup routine.

NYX Epic Ink Eyeliner - Up to 24HR Wear, Midnight Rise

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner, Up To 24HR Wear, Mid Night Rise

Pros

  • Long-lasting wear that can withstand various conditions, including humidity and sweat.
  • Variety of shades provides flexibility for different styles and occasions.
  • Great for both beginners and experienced makeup users due to its easy application process.
  • The fine brush tip offers control for creating meticulous designs.

Cons

  • Some users may find the formula slightly difficult to remove compared to non-waterproof eyeliners.
  • A few shades might not appear as vibrant as expected on certain skin tones.

Key Features

  • Ultra-Precise Brush Tip: The unique design ensures saturated lines with just one stroke.
  • Waterproof Formula: Enjoy smudge-proof, flake-resistant wear throughout your busy day.
  • 15 Shades Available: Choose from matte, glitter, and metallic finishes tailored to various moods and occasions.
  • Easy Application: The smooth fluidity allows both beginners and seasoned veterans to achieve their desired looks effortlessly.
  • Cruelty-Free: Certified by PETA, NYX does not test on animals, aligning with ethical beauty practices.
  • 2025 Allure Best of Beauty Winner: Recognized for excellence in the beauty community.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner is designed for those who seek precision and durability in their eye makeup. With its waterproof formula, this liquid eyeliner promises up to 24 hours of wear, making it suitable for any occasion—whether it’s a casual day out or an extravagant night at a festival. The flexible brush tip allows for smooth application, giving you the freedom to create everything from subtle lines to dramatic winged looks.

NYX Epic Inky Stix Eyeliner - Waterproof Cream Gel - Black

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Inky Stix Eyeliner, Mechanical Cream Gel Eyeliner, Waterproof Formula With Up To 24HR Wear - 01 Black Screen (Matte Black)

Pros

  • Long-lasting: The 24-hour wear means you can apply it in the morning and not worry about touch-ups.
  • Vibrant pigmentation: Delivers intense color that stands out without multiple applications.
  • Versatility: Suitable for various eyeliner styles, catering to both classic and trendy looks.
  • User-friendly: The mechanical design eliminates the need for sharpening and makes application simple.
  • Smudge-resistant: Maintains a clean look throughout the day, even in humid conditions.

Cons

  • Limited color options: Although there are 13 shades, some users may wish for an even broader palette.
  • May require skill: While the slanted tip is precise, some beginners might find it tricky at first.
  • Price point: Slightly higher compared to other drugstore brands, which may deter budget shoppers.

Key Features

  • Epic Inky Color: Enjoy fluid color with just one swipe for effortless application.
  • Waterproof Formula: Designed to withstand water and humidity for extended wear.
  • Ultra-Precise Slanted Tip: Perfect for achieving both thick and thin lines.
  • Quick-Dry Feature: The eyeliner dries quickly to prevent smudges and flakes.
  • Cruelty-Free: Certified by PETA, ensuring no animal testing involved.

Specifications

  • Product Type: Mechanical Cream Gel Eyeliner
  • Shade: 01 Black Screen (Matte Black)
  • Weight: Standard pencil size for ease of use
  • Allergies: Always perform a patch test if you have sensitive skin

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Inky Stix Eyeliner is a game changer in the world of eye makeup. With its unique waterproof formula, this mechanical cream gel eyeliner promises to deliver vibrant color that lasts for up to 24 hours. If you're seeking an eyeliner that allows you to create everything from subtle wings to bold graphic lines without the fuss of brushes, then this product might just be what you need.

NYX Professional Makeup Always Onyx Mechanical Eye Pencil

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil,Vivid Rich Mechanical, Creamy Retractable Eyeliner - Always Onyx, Black Eyeliner

Pros

  • Easy Application: The creamy formula glides on smoothly for precise lines.
  • Long-Lasting Wear: Stays in place all day without fading or bleeding.
  • Versatility: Suitable for both subtle daytime looks and bold evening styles.
  • Eco-Conscious Choice: A cruelty-free option for ethical consumers.

Cons

  • Color Options: Some users may find the range limited if they're looking for very specific shades.
  • Price Point: While affordable, it may not be budget-friendly for everyone compared to drugstore alternatives.

Key Features

  • Retractable Design: No sharpening required; simply twist up to use.
  • Intense Pigmentation: Offers the coverage of a liquid eyeliner with a smooth creaminess.
  • Smudge Proof: Resistant to smudging, keeping your eye makeup intact through heat and humidity.
  • Cruelty-Free: Certified by PETA; no animal testing involved in any product.
  • Variety of Shades: Available in multiple colors from neutral to bright, suitable for various eye makeup styles.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil in Always Onyx is designed for those who seek a reliable and versatile eyeliner. With its vivid, rich color and creamy formulation, this retractable eyeliner promises to deliver an effortless application for anyone looking to create striking eye looks.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner - Waterproof Eyeliner

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner with Vegan Formula - Dark Chocolate (Dark Brown Matte)

Pros

  • Long-Lasting: Offers impressive longevity with up to 24 hours of wear.
  • Easy Application: The flexible tip makes it simple to create various line thicknesses.
  • Diverse Shade: The Dark Chocolate color is versatile and flattering for all skin tones.
  • Cruelty-Free: A responsible choice for ethical consumers as it's PETA certified.

Cons

  • Initial Drying Time: May require a few moments to fully dry, so careful blinking is advised right after application.
  • Color Selection: Limited to fewer shades compared to other brands, which may not suit everyone’s preference.

Key Features

  • Vegan Formula: Perfect for those seeking cruelty-free cosmetics.
  • Waterproof: Ensures smudge-proof wear throughout the day.
  • Flake-Resistant: Maintains a flawless appearance without flaking.
  • Flexible Brush Tip: Allows for precise application, whether you prefer thin lines or bold cat-eye flicks.
  • Matte Finish: Provides a sleek, modern look suitable for any occasion.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner in Dark Chocolate is a standout product among liquid eyeliners, particularly for those who appreciate a vegan formula and a matte finish. This waterproof eyeliner promises up to 24 hours of wear, making it an excellent choice for long days or special events. The unique s'more-inspired shade offers rich pigmentation that can effortlessly enhance your eye looks.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Finish Setting Spray - Vegan Formula

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray - Matte Finish, Long-Lasting Face Mist for up to 16HR Wear, Vegan Formula

Pros

  • Effective Performance: Users report that it keeps makeup intact for an impressive duration.
  • Lightweight Texture: The spray feels comfortable on the skin without adding any heaviness.
  • Versatile Use: Suitable for various makeup styles and products, making it a versatile addition to your routine.
  • Ethically Made: Strong commitment to cruelty-free practices, appealing to conscious consumers.

Cons

  • Limited Availability: Some users may find it difficult to locate specific variants or shades.
  • Scented Formula: While many enjoy the fragrance, others may prefer an unscented option.

Key Features

  • Matte Finish: Achieve a shine-free look that stays fresh and vibrant all day long.
  • Long-Lasting Formula: Extends wear time of your makeup up to 16 hours for those busy days or nights out.
  • Compatible with All Makeup Types: Works seamlessly with foundation, eyeshadow, and powder products.
  • Cruelty-Free: Certified by PETA, ensuring that no animals were harmed in the making of this product.
  • Easy Application: Simply shake the bottle and spray from approximately 6 inches away for best results.

If you’re on the hunt for a reliable setting spray that ensures your makeup lasts throughout the day, the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray might just be what you need. This product is designed specifically to provide a matte finish while keeping your makeup intact for up to 16 hours. With its lightweight formula, it promises comfort without compromising on performance.

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner - Smudge-Proof & Waterproof

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner | Smudge-Proof, Waterproof Eyeliner | Precise 8-Hour Wear Liner For Everyday And Dramatic Eye Looks

Pros

  • Easy to apply with great control due to its gel consistency.
  • Long-lasting performance minimizes the need for touch-ups.
  • Wide range of colors available for versatile beauty options.
  • Suitable for everyday use and special occasions alike.

Cons

  • Some users might find it requires a specific brush for optimal application.
  • May require an oil-based remover for complete removal.

Key Features

  • Creates versatile looks, ranging from subtle to dramatic.
  • Ultra-precise application similar to liquid liners.
  • Long-wear, stay-put formula that resists smudging and fading.
  • Waterproof design ensures durability in varying conditions.
  • Resistant to sweat and humidity for all-day wear.

The Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner is designed for those who want to achieve both subtle and dramatic eye looks with ease. Its gel-based formula offers the precision of a liquid liner, making it accessible for everyone from makeup novices to seasoned pros. This smudge-proof and waterproof eyeliner promises an impressive wear time of up to 8 hours, allowing you to maintain that perfect look throughout your busy day.

The 20 Best Eyeliner Pencils I’ve Tried for Bold Looks – Price, Ratings, Reviews & Sales Insights

Product Name Image Price Rating Review Count Expert ScoreSales Last MonthBuy
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner - Waterproof Black Eyeliner$9.99
(4.5)
107779 96 40000 Get it on Amazon
NYX Professional Makeup Always Onyx Mechanical Eye Pencil$7.97
(4.5)
103410 85 9000 Get it on Amazon
NYX Epic Ink Eyeliner - Up to 24HR Wear, Midnight Rise$9.97
(4.5)
107780 81 10 Get it on Amazon
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner - Waterproof Eyeliner$9.97
(4.5)
105721 81 10 Get it on Amazon
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Finish Setting Spray - Vegan Formula$9.97
(4.5)
91552 80 10 Get it on Amazon
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Aqua Green Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil$8.89
(4.4)
25692 74 500 Get it on Amazon
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP The Brow Glue Eyebrow Gel - Extreme Hold$9.97
(4.4)
35658 74 10 Get it on Amazon
SNAILGIRL Waterproof Brown Eyeliner Pencil - Long-Wear Gel$12.99
(5.0)
3 74 10 Get it on Amazon
Aqua Resist Smoky Shadow - 6 Earth by Make Up For Ever$26.99
(5.0)
5 72 10 Get it on Amazon
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner - Smudge-Proof & WaterproofUnlock the price
(4.4)
1005 72 10 Get it on Amazon
NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Stick - Pitch Black$8.99
(4.2)
12375 71 10 Get it on Amazon
Artist Color Pencil - Limitless Brown by Make Up For Ever$25.55
(4.6)
460 71 900 Get it on Amazon
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Eyeliner - All-Day Pigment-Rich LinerUnlock the price
(4.2)
91 71 10 Get it on Amazon
Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner Pencil - Xtreme BlackUnlock the price
(4.0)
12 70 10 Get it on Amazon
Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl Longwear Eyeliner Pencil$28.0
(4.6)
1507 70 10 Get it on Amazon
Artist Color Pencil - 506 Endless Cacao by Make Up For Ever$20.5
(4.5)
229 70 600 Get it on Amazon
NYX Epic Inky Stix Eyeliner - Waterproof Cream Gel - Black$12.97
(4.2)
1238 70 10 Get it on Amazon
Aqua Resist Color Pencil - 2 Ebony Eyeliner by Make Up For Ever$27.46
(4.5)
53 69 10 Get it on Amazon
Lancôme Dual Finish Longwear Powder Foundation - Natural Matte$45.05
(4.7)
3904 69 10 Get it on Amazon
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Lip Lingerie Liner - All-Day Color$11.97
(4.1)
1715 69 10 Get it on Amazon
Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Waterline Eyeliner Pencil$19.55
(4.1)
2558 69 10 Get it on Amazon
Lancôme Drama 24H Longwear Waterproof Eyeliner Gel Pencil$26.0
(4.2)
502 68 10 Get it on Amazon
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eyeliner Stick - Waterproof & Pigment-Rich$34.0
(4.4)
223 68 10 Get it on Amazon
Aqua Resist Graphic Pen - Black | Make Up For Ever Eyeliner$24.0
(4.1)
29 68 100 Get it on Amazon
Bobbi Brown 24-Hour Kajal Liner Waterproof | High-Intensity Eyeliner$28.0
(4.1)
69 67 10 Get it on Amazon
Bobbi Brown Dual-Ended Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick - 24-Hour$43.0
(4.2)
157 66 10 Get it on Amazon
Aqua Resist Color Pencil - Limitless Brown Eyeliner by Make Up For Ever$27.16
(1.0)
1 52 10 Get it on Amazon